Risk Assessment and Mitigation Program (RAMP)
Since September 2015, the California Dungeness Crab Fishing Gear Working Group (Working Group) has been taking steps to actively identify and be responsive to elevated risks of whale entanglements in California Dungeness crab fishing gear. This unique coalition of diverse stakeholders—which includes commercial and recreational fishermen, environmental organization representatives, members of the whale entanglement response network and state and federal agencies—is committed to developing solutions that support thriving whale populations along the West Coast and a thriving and profitable Dungeness crab fishery. For a Fact Sheet about the Working Group and other background information, visit the California Dungeness Crab Fishing Gear Working Group webpage.
Risk Assessment and Mitigation Program (RAMP)
A Risk Assessment and Mitigation Program (RAMP) has been developed by the Working Group to assess circumstances where entanglement risk may be elevated and, as needed, identify a possible management measures for the CDFW’s Director’s consideration (see Senate Bill 1309 here.) The program is designed to be flexible and responsive to considering new information, technologies, and approaches to reducing the risk of entanglements.
Building on lessons learned during the 2017-18 RAMP Pilot (here and here), the Working Group has fine-tuned the RAMP for the 2018-19 fishing season. The Working Group is scheduled to convene four times to conduct a pre, mid, late, and postseason risk assessment. A subgroup of Working Group (Evaluation Team) may also be convened by the agencies in response to elevated entanglement risk. All RAMP related discussions, risk evaluations, and possible management recommendations developed by the Evaluation Team will be posted on this webpage and circulated via the Working Group’s email distribution list. If you are interested in receiving these updates via email, please contact email@example.com. The Working Group welcomes your feedback and insights on the RAMP – visit http://www.opc.ca.gov/whale-entanglement-working-group or contact the Working Group at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Entanglement Risk Low to Moderate in Northern Management Area
2018-19 Whale Entanglement Risk Assessment & Mitigation Program (RAMP)
On January 11, 2019, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, in partnership with the Ocean Protection Council*, convened the California Dungeness Crab Fishing Gear Working Group (Working Group)’s Evaluation Team to proactively discuss and assess the relative risk of entanglements in advance of the January 15, 2019 Northern Management Area partial opener (see here for more details). Due to the Federal government shutdown and other circumstances, the Working Group had limited participation from federal partners and access to information across the four risk factors. The Working Group identified the following risk levels for humpback and blue whales:
More information and rationale for the scoring of each factor is available here (also see “Summary” section below for additional details). In summary, the delayed northern opener increases the potential for high concentrations of fishing gear in areas where migrating and feeding whales may be present. To minimize the potential for whale entanglements, the commercial fleet and recreational fishing community are requested to follow the recommendations outlined in the 2018-19 Best Practices Guide, with specific attention to the setup of surface gear. Fishermen should be on alert and avoid fishing in areas where there are groups of feeding whales and/or schools of anchovy or swarms of krill.
Fishermen, particularly those fishing in the Northern Management Area, are encouraged to share observations of whale activity and ocean conditions (e.g., are you seeing schools of anchovy, and if so, what depth contour?) to help inform the Working Group’s efforts. Text 310-738-2665 or email email@example.com.
The Working Group anticipates changes in the distribution and concentrations of whales, particularly in the Central Management Area as we head into the spring months, and all risk factors will continue to be monitored closely and responded to as needed. Fishermen are encouraged to fish as minimal gear as possible and must remove any gear that cannot be serviced every 96 hours.
The Working Group will meet in mid-February to re-evaluate entanglement risk looking ahead to the spring fishing season unless the agencies identify a need to meet sooner, and will continue to inform the industry as new updates are available.
This update will be shared via the DCTF email list, the Working Group webpage, and CDFW’s crab webpage. The Working Group welcomes your feedback and insights about the Working Group’s efforts and the 2018-19 RAMP. Please visit http://www.opc.ca.gov/whale-entanglement-working-group or contact the Working Group at firstname.lastname@example.org.
* The January 11, 2019 Evaluation Team call involved limited participation from National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Fisheries staff due to the partial Federal government shutdown.
** The Working Group developed the following risk assessment based on limited information, particularly for the whale concentrations and forage/ocean conditions factors. Additional evaluation of these factors will be conducted once resources and personnel are in place to help review available data and provide an expert assessment.
In November and December of 2018, there were three (3) confirmed entanglement reports and one (1) unconfirmed in California. Of the three confirmed, two (2) entanglements were confirmed as humpback whales and involved unidentified fishing gear, and the other confirmed entanglement involved CA commercial Dungeness crab gear, however, the whale species was unidentified. During the January 11 call, the National Marine Fisheries Service provided preliminary entanglement numbers for 2018 in CA (36 reports, 27 confirmed) and on the West Coast (CA, OR, WA) (56 reports, 43 confirmed). The Working Group highlighted the importance of considering the cumulative number of 2018 entanglements, particularly those occurring in May-August, during this evaluation and the mid-season risk assessment scheduled for February.
Limited whale concentration and forage/ocean condition information was available to help inform Working Group discussions. A recent El Niño/Southern Oscillation (ENSO) report indicates that despite the above-average ocean temperatures across the equatorial Pacific Ocean, the overall coupled ocean-atmosphere system continued to reflect ENSO-neutral (here). Mixed observations were provided by fishermen and whale watch operators on the concentration and distribution of forage, with anchovies reported in the shipping lanes from Bodega Head to Point Pinos, as well as south of Point Pinos to Cypress Point. Observed concentrations of humpback whales in the Central Management Area by both whale watch operators and fishermen appear to be low compared to this time last year. Blue whales have migrated south and have not been observed in the Central Management Area. Price for crab has decreased since the opening of the Central Management Area and is not expected to rise due to the multiple openers anticipated in the north. Fishermen reported the northern opener(s) are not expected to result in high gear concentrations in those areas, and gear concentrations will decrease within 2-3 weeks after the opener. Fishing in the Central Management Area was observed to be decreasing due to the low price and crabs beginning to clutch. Based on the information available, the Evaluation Team assessed the risk in the Central Management Area as low and the as low to moderate in the Northern Management Area.
2018-19 RAMP Risk Assessments
- 2018-19 RAMP Evaluation Team Assessment – January 11, 2019
- 2018-19 RAMP Preseason Assessment – October 30 & November 6, 2018
- 2018-19 RAMP Overview
- Draft RAMP Guiding Principles (updated August 2018)
- Draft 2018-19 RAMP Assumptions
- Draft Management Measures Toolbox (MMT) (updated August 2018)
2017-18 RAMP Reflections and Lessons Learned
- 2017-18 RAMP Pilot Reflections and Lessons Learned, July 2018
- 2017-18 RAMP Pilot Draft Risk Assessment Framework Key Findings, August 2018
PDFs of Status Updates & Recommendations:
- RAMP Pilot Post-Season Risk Assessment and Evaluation Team Update – July 2018
- RAMP Pilot Risk Assessment & Evaluation Team Update – June 2018
- RAMP Pilot Risk Assessment and Evaluation Team Update – March 2018
- 2017-2018 Updates & Recommendations to Reduce Risk of Whale Entanglements – January 10, 2018
- RAMP Pilot Risk Assessment and Evaluation Team Update – January 3, 2018
- RAMP Pilot Aerial Survey Update – December 2017
- RAMP Pilot Evaluation Team Update – November 30, 2017
- RAMP Pilot Pre-Season Risk Assessment and Evaluation Team Update – October 26 & November 6, 2017
Contact the Working Group at email@example.com
Ocean Protection Council
- Paige Berube: firstname.lastname@example.org
Facilitation Team: Strategic Earth Consulting